Skip to content

Agency

About Coffee & Candle

A London brand and marketing consultancy that starts with strategy and finishes with the work.

Men from MarsBridging the gap between innovation and confidence.See the project
ContactBook a consultation
Book a consultationConsultation
How to Run a Brand Audit: A Step-by-Step Guide With a Checklist

How to Run a Brand Audit: A Step-by-Step Guide With a Checklist

A brand audit shows what is working and where to focus. Follow this step-by-step guide to audit your brand’s strategy, visuals, voice and perception.

Coffee & Candle5 min read7 Oct 2026
Link copied

A brand audit is a proper look at how your brand looks, sounds and performs, compared with how it should. It turns “something feels off” into a list of specific things you can fix. It’s the sensible first step before a rebrand, a refresh, or even a big marketing push.

In this article

What it covers

There are two sides:

  • Inside: what you say you are, and what you actually put out.
  • Outside: how customers, prospects and competitors see you.

The useful stuff is almost always in the gap between the two.

Step 1: Decide what you want to find out

Start with a question. For example:

  • Do we need a rebrand, or just a refresh?
  • Why do we keep losing to the same competitors?
  • Are we consistent across channels?
  • Will the brand hold up in a new market?

A clear question stops the audit sprawling.

Step 2: Look at your strategy

Gather whatever you have on positioning, values, audiences and messaging. Then ask:

  • Is there a clear positioning statement?
  • Do leaders and staff describe the business the same way?
  • Are your target audiences defined, and still accurate?
  • Do the values show up in how people behave, or just on the wall?

If none of this is written down anywhere, that’s your first finding.

Step 3: Gather everything with your brand on it

Make a list of every place the brand appears:

  • Website, landing pages, email templates
  • Social profiles and recent posts
  • Packaging, signs and printed materials
  • Sales decks, proposals, invoices
  • Customer service scripts and automated messages
  • Job ads, uniforms, merchandise

Screenshot or photograph it all and lay it side by side. The inconsistencies tend to jump out.

Step 4: Check the visuals

For each one:

  • Is it the right logo, with enough space around it?
  • Are colours and fonts consistent?
  • Do the images feel like they belong together?
  • Is the quality the same everywhere, or does one channel let the rest down?

Compare it all against your brand guidelines, if you have them.

Step 5: Check the words

Read your copy as if you’d never heard of the business. Look at:

  • Headlines and descriptions
  • Calls to action
  • Emails and support replies
  • Social captions

Does it all sound like the same company? Does it match the tone of voice you meant to have?

Step 6: Study competitors

Pick three to six and compare:

  • How they position themselves, and what they claim
  • How they look
  • How they sound
  • Price signals and proof

Note where you overlap and where you’re different. If you could swap your logo onto their website and nobody would notice, you’re not different enough.

Step 7: Ask customers

Talk to real people:

  • Short interviews with recent customers, long-standing ones, and ones you lost
  • A survey to your email list
  • Reviews and testimonials, read for the words that keep coming up
  • Your sales team, on the objections and misunderstandings they hear

Good questions: what do you think we do? Why did you choose us? What would you tell a friend? What nearly put you off?

Step 8: Look at the numbers

Put some data next to the opinions:

  • Where website traffic comes from, and how it converts
  • How visible you are in search, for your name and your category
  • Social engagement and follower growth
  • Sales conversion and average deal size
  • How many customers stay, and how many refer others

You’re looking for patterns. Lots of people searching your name but almost nobody finding you for your category, for instance.

Step 9: Pull it together

Sort what you found into four groups:

  1. Strengths to protect
  2. Weaknesses to fix
  3. Opportunities in the market
  4. Risks from competitors or perception gaps

Rank them by impact and effort. You want a short list of actions, not a fat report.

Step 10: Decide what happens next

It usually ends up as one of these:

  • Not much: a tidy-up and better guidelines
  • A refresh: updated visuals and materials
  • A repositioning: rethinking the strategy
  • A full rebrand: new strategy, identity, and sometimes a new name

Our list of signs you need a rebrand helps you judge the scale, and the rebrand process, step by step shows what comes after.

A quick self-check

Score each from 1 (poor) to 5 (strong):

  • How clear your positioning is
  • How different you are from competitors
  • Visual consistency
  • Consistency in how you sound
  • How well customers understand what you do
  • Whether the experience matches the promise

Anything at 3 or below needs attention.

Frequently asked questions

How often should I audit my brand?

Every year or two, and whenever the business or the market changes a lot.

Can I do it myself?

The visual and written review, yes. The customer and competitor parts usually benefit from someone outside, because people inside the business are too close to it.

How long does it take?

For a small business, a focused audit can take a couple of weeks. Bigger organisations take longer.

Can you run one for us?

Yes. An audit is where a lot of our projects start. Book a brand consultation to talk yours through.

Our work, in the press. And our clients, on the shelf.

Book a brand consultation

Tell us where the business is today and where you want it to go. You’ll hear back from a person, not an autoresponder.

1 chair to 3 branchesHestory grew from 200 to 11,000 customers and from 6,000 to 120,000 followers. See the project
Fill in the sentence. Six quick blanks.
One of our team will be in touch within one working day to arrange a call.
A 30-minute call about what your brand needs next.

Prefer to pick a time now? Book a call directly

Recent clients: Hestory, Men From Mars, Beacon Hill Healthcare

Fill in this form to book your consultation. Complete each blank below, then press the button. Name and email are required.

Hi, I’m from I need help with and our budget is Reply to me at I found you through

Add a note (optional)

Free 30-minute call, no obligation. We reply within one working day.
We only use your details to reply. See our privacy policy.